Yes, there are shirts out there! And those who have them have agreed to forward them to those who follow!
The original shirt was to reassure the owner's mother three days after his heart surgery. Showing the stapled wound was to prove authenticity. The shirt was worn because it was silk, and didn't irritate the healing area. The design on the shirt was gratuitous. The pose was to show that he really was feeling all right.
The Order was started because the picture was posted to give others a positive example of how surgery can turn out. Another member (StrechL) asked if he would forward the "good luck shirt" to be worn by him after surgery as well. A certificate was made, signed photos of the shirt-wearers were added, and the shirt began to be forwarded around. Then there was need for another, and the old box in the attic was raided again for another billious silk shirt that was worn during recovery, and a second and third shirt began the rounds.
The notion is that you take a picture in the shirt shortly after your surgery, post it here, and include a signed, dated copy of it with the shirt. The obligation (the only obligation) is that when the next person is ready to use a Tawdry shirt, you wash it and mail it (with the certificate and photos) to that person. Sort of a fashion-faux-pas chain letter, with mild gore.
It's just a novel way to share the experience with each other, and to make the comradeship felt through the website more real through the medium of the cloth, however silly.
And they don't need to be just on new newbies. You still qualify as long as you've had any type of valve surgery (that, of course, includes repairs). It's just a little more effective when the awful reality of the sight-searing shirt is balanced by the muted gruesomeness of a freshly stapled, not-yet-healed, chest scar.
But no, the base membership qualification can never be taken away.
JC, you get in for earnestness and a really nice scar set display, but that shirt is not nearly wretched and jarring enough to the sensibilities...
Best wishes,