A neat little documentary

Valve Replacement Forums

Help Support Valve Replacement Forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

yotphix

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 14, 2009
Messages
409
Location
Canada
Hi folks,

For anyone who is interested, there is a neat little documentary here http://www.cbc.ca/video/#/News/Health/1244503490/ID=1687984339
about a fantastic valve surgeon, also featuring his most excellent patient ;) .

I haven't seen the whole thing myself yet but I should warn that there is actual footage of my open chest so if you are squeemish or nervous you may want to stay away.

Paul
 
Thanks that was really interesting. Was this on the regular news or one of those prime times news type shows, since it seems long for the nightly news.? It was really well done and and I really liked the one year update. Did they show this a 2nd time and add the updates or did it take that long to get to air?
Your surgeon seems like a really caring guy. I was surprised when he said the ave number of surgeries the US heart surgeon does is 80 a year, (that seems odd since that is less than 2 a week) and a Canadian one averages 200. It was interesting seeing the different rooms too, do all the patient rooms have a couple beds?
What nice looking couples both you and your surgeon and wives are too Congradulations on the marriage, I loved watching how concerned your wife was when you were talking to your surgeon pre op, the love between the both of you really shined thru.

(for anyone concerned, it isn't that graphic for the most part altho you do see Pauls and another guys heart)
 
Paul,
I see that is Sunnybrook ?
I want an autographed copy
Do you ever get the urge to kiss a cod after all the newfie talk in the OR ?

That is Sunnybrook. And I've always kind of had a cod kissing urge but that might just be my maritime heritage showing. In an odd sort of way it is comforting to see what is a huge event for us be a day at the office for them isn't it? Jokes and music and all.

I'm still figuring out how I can save it myself. It's not really downloadable from the site. With luck they'll hook me up at the CBC.
 
What a wonderful documentary that shows the 'human' side of heart surgery from both the patient and doctor perspective. Your surgeon seems very down to earth as well as very committed to his patients/profession. That is certainly reassuring.
I, too would like to personally congratulate you on your marriage! Also, thanks for sharing a very personal and life changing surgical experience with us. I am sure this will help those who are or will be travelling down this path.

Best wishes,
 
Thanks that was really interesting. Was this on the regular news or one of those prime times news type shows, since it seems long for the nightly news.? It was really well done and and I really liked the one year update. Did they show this a 2nd time and add the updates or did it take that long to get to air?
Your surgeon seems like a really caring guy. I was surprised when he said the ave number of surgeries the US heart surgeon does is 80 a year, (that seems odd since that is less than 2 a week) and a Canadian one averages 200. It was interesting seeing the different rooms too, do all the patient rooms have a couple beds?
What nice looking couples both you and your surgeon and wives are too Congradulations on the marriage, I loved watching how concerned your wife was when you were talking to your surgeon pre op, the love between the both of you really shined thru.


(for anyone concerned, it isn't that graphic for the most part altho you do see Pauls and another guys heart)

It did take that long to get to air. I had been wondering what happened to it until I had a call just a few days before the wedding in October asking me for an update. I actually didn't see it on air myself since I'm not in Canada just now. I think it was aired as a part of a series about health care professionals which shows after the nightly news.

You're not the first woman I know to have pointed out what a handsome fellow Dr. Cohen is! My mothers went on about him for weeks.

From my limited experience (Sunnybrook and Toronto General) cardiac recovery rooms have two or three beds. If you have a supplementary insurance plan it may afford you a private room though.

Thanks for the kind words and the congratulations.

Paul
 
What a wonderful documentary that shows the 'human' side of heart surgery from both the patient and doctor perspective. Your surgeon seems very down to earth as well as very committed to his patients/profession. That is certainly reassuring.
I, too would like to personally congratulate you on your marriage! Also, thanks for sharing a very personal and life changing surgical experience with us. I am sure this will help those who are or will be travelling down this path.

Best wishes,

Thank you very much!
I could never say enough great things about Dr. Cohen. He is kind, attentive, genuine and, by all accounts, supremely skilled. I feel quite fortunate that he was my Cardiologist's first choice for a surgeon.
 
One thing that I found intersting was the fact that there are a TOTAL of 140 Cardiac Surgeons in Canada and we have four here in Kitchenner and I believe that my surgeon practiced with Dr Cohen at TGH but was at the Montreal Heart Institute prior to that
 
Very cool documentary. With only 180 cardiac surgeons in Canada, does that mean long waiting lists for surgery?

You would think that wouldn't you? I can't say what it is like if you don't happen to live in a Metropolis like Toronto. I do know that when I was told I needed to have surgery, I was told that it was up to me to pick any one of the following six months. (Longer would have been putting the heart in danger.) I met several people who had surgery within days of diagnosis. My brother-in-law went in to Richmond Hill (a smaller suburban centre though with a large hospital serving the surrounding area) one day with chest pain and had bypass surgery four days later. It doesn't seem to be a problem.

Are there more than 1400 in the US? (Your population is ten times ours!)

I looked and didn't find statistics on the numbers of them but I did find this odd little article from a few years ago stating that there isn't enough work for them all!
http://www.usatoday.com/money/industries/health/2007-02-13-cardiac-jobs-usat_x.htm
And this more detailed article from 2004
http://www.ctsnet.org/sections/newsandviews/inmyopinion/articles/article-7.html
 
No waiting....I was done in 12 days....There were several cardiac surgeons in Montreal, or I could have gone to Ottawa where there are several more.


Bina is correct as always ....provincial average is 28 days but here is a list by hospital http://www.health.gov.on.ca/en/ for me I was in On the 8th angio that day and they could operate on the 11th
 
Good to hear. Was just asking out of curiosity, let me hasten to say -- not trying to make any point. The young surgeon in the film appears to be quite impressive. Was a nice story to report.
 
Good to hear. Was just asking out of curiosity, let me hasten to say -- not trying to make any point. The young surgeon in the film appears to be quite impressive. Was a nice story to report.

Don't worry, despite the ambassador feeling that we have an inferiority complex, (you may not have heard of the leaked cable that was described in but we have heard it non-stop -not much else going on I guess) we in Ontario generally feel pretty secure about our medical system! It is a valid question though. I do fear that Doctor Cohen and his colleagues work too much. He seems comfortable with up to 80 hours/week now, and 6 or 8 surgeries but how long can he sustain? Maybe some of the surplus doctors mentioned in the articles I posted links to could move up here?
 
Bina is correct as always ....provincial average is 28 days but here is a list by hospital http://www.health.gov.on.ca/en/ for me I was in On the 8th angio that day and they could operate on the 11th

Do you know, I looked at that list and it said that the least average time to completion from diagnosis in the Greater Metropolitan Toronto area was nearly two months. This tells you the average but ignores that time is dependant on need. Everyone who I know that has needed a procedure immediately has had it. Those who can wait, do. Seems like a good set up really.
 
I would double-check Canadian stats on the US health system, based on the info I've seen about the Canadian system coming North across the border! But in general, one (an economist) would expect the supply of top-level well-paid surgeons to increase until they were under-subscribed (think Maytag repair guy?), unless there were controls. Those could come from med schools, professional societies, or government agencies, and they may well work differently in the US and Canada.

I had a funny experience with the waiting list issue, myself. In general, some parts of the Canadian and Ontario health-care system HAVE experienced lengthening waiting lists, and they've become a political issue, mostly since ~3-4 yrs ago, both provincially and federally. We have several programs to try to decrease them, and to disclose them.

When I saw Dr. Feindel last June, I thought that November (last month) sounded like a reasonable time for my OHS. I suggested to him that we "block in" a date in early November -- I thought it was like buying a plane ticket far in advance -- and he recoiled in horror! "I can't do that!"

"Why not?"

"If I booked you for heart surgery 5 months in advance, it would jump off the page at the bureaucrats as an unacceptably long waiting time, and would skew our whole average! They'd come down on us like a tonne of bricks." He explained that there was essentially no REAL waiting list at all, so if I wanted surgery in November, I should call in October and get the ball rolling.

I left him a "let's do it" phone message on Oct. 20, and I got to see him on Nov. 3. He offered me a number of surgery dates in November, which didn't work well with my schedule, so I chose Dec. 1. I have no complaints about the scheduling process, though the bureaucratic pressure worked in a slightly strange way!

(BTW, I got bumped ~ 4 hours the day before surgery, when an emergency got slipped in. I think that happens occasionally in all systems.)
 
Last edited:
Thanks for sharing that Paul. Really worthwhile. I'm having an angio on Monday to determine how soon I need my bicuspid valve replaced. I'm 42, married with a little girl and my own business in Melbourne, Oz. I checked your profile and see you had an AVR. I'm confused that your heart was beating in the doco - don't they stop the heart and put it on bypass? Or was it just at a certain stage of the op? How do you feel now? And how do you feel when you look at that video? Does it seem real that it's your heart they are holding??? Can your wife watch it ok? (In case it's obvious, my business is asking questions - I'm a freelance journalist :)
 
It was an interesting documentary, thanks for sharing.
Dr Cohen I think must have been chosen for his bedside manner, most of the medical specialists I have come across are not nearly as jovial or chatty.
In the recovery ward scene the guy had some kind of heart shaped red balloon on his chest, I never saw anything remotely like it in hospital, any clues on what it was???
 

Latest posts

Back
Top