Contribution vs. Commitment

Shop deals on ebay
shop deals on amazon
Advertise with us
Valve Replacement Forums

Help Support Valve Replacement Forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
G

Guest

The following quote greeted us on the company computer system the other day:

Always remember the distinction between contribution and commitment. Take the matter of bacon and eggs. The chicken makes a contribution. The pig makes a commitment.
--- John Mack Carter
Click to expand...

But ... isn't "contribution" a way to show "commitment"?

Thoughts?



Cort:34swm."Mr Monte Carlo.Mr Road Trip".pig valve&pacemaker
WRMNshowcase.legos.HO.models.MCs.RTs.CHD = http://www.chevyasylum.com/cort
"Are we too blind to see?" ... Elvis Presley ... 'In The Ghetto'
 
knightfan2691 said:
The following quote greeted us on the company computer system the other day:



But ... isn't "contribution" a way to show "commitment"?

Thoughts?



Cort:34swm."Mr Monte Carlo.Mr Road Trip".pig valve&pacemaker
WRMNshowcase.legos.HO.models.MCs.RTs.CHD = http://www.chevyasylum.com/cort
"Are we too blind to see?" ... Elvis Presley ... 'In The Ghetto'
Click to expand...

I do not have the commitment required to contribute to this thread:rolleyes::p
 
Well that type of "committment" one can only give once:eek:,
I think it makes more sense to contribute over a long period of time,
and with this the contributer would be more committed than the committed:confused:
--Dina
 
The question is too simplistic.
Within the philosophical metaphysics of response to life's ultimate questions; how would my breakfast choice of oatmeal porridge with added nuts and raisins instead of bacon and eggs lie?
 
And don't forget that it may be said that contribution is merely a manner of involvement. Then we must consider the difference between involvement and commitment. Think of it like your bacon and eggs for breakfast -- The hen was involved. . . the pig was committed.
 
Cort, it sounds like some corporate "human resources" flack was tasked with presenting the canned thought of the day. Obviously you can make a contribution in some token way without having a real commitment to a cause. Beware the corporate objective to having organization men and women.

Am I committed? No, but I did just realize I had the same breakfast as Bonzo Dog -- oatmeal with raisins. Breakfast of superheroes? :D:D:D
 
I've read that quote before and liked it on the surface. But it is also specious, in the way the elements are defined for you, and if it is misapplied. It's actually the owners of the company who have the exposure and thus are entitled to enjoy the bacon as a result, so to speak. But when the time comes to trim the fat, sometimes the chickens are the ones who get prematurely plucked :eek: .
 
Susan BAV said:
I've read that quote before and liked it on the surface. But it is also specious, in the way the elements are defined for you, and if it is misapplied. It's actually the owners of the company who have the exposure and thus are entitled to enjoy the bacon as a result, so to speak. But when the time comes to trim the fat, sometimes the chickens are the ones who get prematurely plucked :eek: .
Click to expand...


Well said, Susan!!

Sometimes don't we all hear a quote that reverberates for awhile, but then upon further inspection, loses it's impact? This seems to be one of those. Clever, but not that good.

When I saw your headline, I thought you were going to talk about monetary contributions to Hank's forum!! You know, should we set up a committment to contribute, or just contribute if and when we want/can :rolleyes:

Marguerite
 
Both the chicken and pig were involved against their will. They now have to find another pig who will be equally "committed", while they will continue to take advantage of the chicken's "contribution". And I guess it could be said that the poor chicks that those eggs could have developed into were as committed as the pig. I think your boss is trying to find a valid reason for mass murder and robbery!

Perhaps we should commit to organizing a committee of historically contributing individuals who are willing to contribute time and effort to evaluating whether or not these forms of contribution and commitment are legal and/or valuable, and if so, which is more commendable - the ongoing efforts of the contributor or the one-time involvement of the committer - or if not, should it be considered a committable offense!
 
Marguerite53 said:
Sometimes don't we all hear a quote that reverberates for awhile, but then upon further inspection, loses it's impact? This seems to be one of those. Clever, but not that good.
Click to expand...

Ah, but see ... I disagree ... slightly.

Yes, it reverberated for a while, but even the more I read it ... the more I wasn't sure how good it was.

And yet...sometimes...those type of quotes are the best ... because it makes you think initially ... then makes you think even more! Kinda like a brain teaser ... only more in depth ;). he he



Cort:34swm."Mr Monte Carlo.Mr Road Trip".pig valve&pacemaker
WRMNshowcase.legos.HO.models.MCs.RTs.CHD = http://www.chevyasylum.com/cort
"I ainít fallin' for you all over again" ... Lee Roy Parnell ... 'What Kind Of Fool Do You Think I Am?'
 
Lisa in Katy said:
Both the chicken and pig were involved against their will. They now have to find another pig who will be equally "committed", while they will continue to take advantage of the chicken's "contribution". And I guess it could be said that the poor chicks that those eggs could have developed into were as committed as the pig. I think your boss is trying to find a valid reason for mass murder and robbery!

Perhaps we should commit to organizing a committee of historically contributing individuals who are willing to contribute time and effort to evaluating whether or not these forms of contribution and commitment are legal and/or valuable, and if so, which is more commendable - the ongoing efforts of the contributor or the one-time involvement of the committer - or if not, should it be considered a committable offense!
Click to expand...
You must be a teacher at 'heart'...you have already made this 5 minute
topic into an hour long classroom discussion.And have started a great
outline for an essay too.
Just dont ask me to write it , I forgot how:confused:
---Dina:)
 
knightfan2691 said:
Ah, but see ... I disagree ... slightly.

Yes, it reverberated for a while, but even the more I read it ... the more I wasn't sure how good it was.

And yet...sometimes...those type of quotes are the best ... because it makes you think initially ... then makes you think even more! Kinda like a brain teaser ... only more in depth ;). he he



Cort:34swm."Mr Monte Carlo.Mr Road Trip".pig valve&pacemaker
WRMNshowcase.legos.HO.models.MCs.RTs.CHD = http://www.chevyasylum.com/cort
"I ainít fallin' for you all over again" ... Lee Roy Parnell ... 'What Kind Of Fool Do You Think I Am?'
Click to expand...

Well, yes! That's a good point. :D

Got any more for us???

Marguerite
 
Dina, You're almost right. I am a former teacher at heart. My last day in the classroom was February 22, 2008. I loved teaching, but it was causing me way too much stress. Now I negotiate hospital managed care contracts and laugh at the people who think that is a stressful job! I also doubled my income in a day.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Back
Top