Who's Watching Idol?

[Guest]

The guys did a lot better this week. I like David Hernandez, and for the girls I like Carly Smithson (the girl from Ireland with the arm tattoo)

 

[njean]

The guys did a lot better this week. I like David Hernandez, and for the girls I like Carly Smithson (the girl from Ireland with the arm tattoo)

My favorite guy is David Archuleta. Funny, but my mother's maiden name was Archuleta. Perhaps we're distant cousins???? I just think he's soooo cute & has a great voice too. My 2nd favorite is David Hernandez - great voice, good looking!

For the girls, I like the gal (can't remember her name right now) w/the wild colored hair.

Well, gotta go soon because elimination night is tonight! Happy watching!

 

[Ross]

Sorry but it no longer thrills me.

 

[Cooker]

We are watching ....but it is not as exciting as it use to be.....Still fun and one of the few things my wife and I really enjoy watching together.

 

[Superbob]

Idol discovered the great Carrie Underwood. Its work is done.

I suggest there should be another choice in your poll: Watch occasionally.

I am no longer glued to the tube; but I still watch some. The judges' comments and antics are getting predictable and wearing thin. The talent pool is getting shallower. Soon the show should either hang it up or have a makeover.

 

[Cooker]

I am no longer glued to the tube; but I still watch some. The judges' comments and antics are getting predictable and wearing thin. The talent pool is getting shallower. Soon the show should either hang it up or have a makeover.

I?m in with SB 100%....Paula and Simon are getting extremely tiresome?..Randy seems to be more of a true judge, not trying to be so cute?Then again maybe it is scripted that way??But it is time for a makeover.

 

[Wise]

Simon said on Regis & Kelly that he has two years left on his contract. He said after his contract that he is being offered more by Idol to NOT be a judge on the show. He said he'll take the money. Sounds like a good plan to me. That may be enough of a run for the series by then anyway.

As far as contestants, we're rooting for David Archuleta. He's got the best voice and the most potential, according to Cindy and me anyway. I think the McCartney & Lennon songbook may prove to be rough going for the contestants next week; we'll see.

 

[EVELYN]

Hi All

David Hernandez is my No. 1 pick.....what a talented young man.....David Archuleta is good, but doesn't have the charisma or stage presence of Hernandez. Cook wasn't bad this week, either or was the guy with the dredlocks whose name slips me at the moment.

Personally, I'm not in love with any of the girls. But if I had to pick one, it would be the chick from Ireland.....

I'm tired of Paula always agreeing with the Randy the Dog man and his "you were a little pitchy"....and Simon, well, he's just Simon.....at least he's not afraid to voice his opinion. It's not getting old for me, yet, but it's not a crisis if we miss it either.

Evelyn

 

[Glenda]

I'm not glued to it but I do like to watch it. If I miss it, no big deal! From the guys I like David Archuleta. He has a beautiful voice and seems so sweet. For the girls, I'm not sure, I can't remember all their names. There was a girl from my town of Joplin, Missouri that I thought would make it to the top 12 but she was kicked out this last week. She was really great and only lived about 2 miles from me. I would have loved to see her make it.

As far as Paula, she acts doped or drunk half the time. Simon is just Simon. Randy's okay.

I wish they would have younger talented children compete. I love to hear children perform.